UN Bans "Defamation of Religion" in Islamic Bid to Curb Free Speech

www.scoop.co.nz - 24 November 2008
UN Bans "Defamation of Religion" in Islamic Bid to Curb Free Speech

Click here for GA draft resolution

Geneva. By a vote of 85 to 50, with 42 abstaining, the UN General Assembly today adopted a draft resolution calling on all countries to alter their legal and constitutional systems to prevent "defamation of religions," asserting that "Islam is frequently and wrongly associated with human rights violations and terrorism."

The decision, sponsored by Islamic states with the support of Venezuela and Belarus, drew immediate protests from human rights activists and legal experts.

"This is just the latest shot in an intensifying campaign of UN resolutions that dangerously seek to import Islamic anti-blasphemy prohibitions into the discourse of international human rights law," said Hillel Neuer, executive director of UN Watch, an indpendent human rights monitoring group in Geneva.

"Human rights were designed to protect individuals -- to guarantee every person free speech and free exercise of religion -- but most certainly not to shield any set of beliefs, religion included."

"These resolutions legitimize the criminalization of free speech in countries like Sudan, Egypt, Pakistan, and Saudi Arabia," said Neuer. "Muslim moderates, bloggers, women seeking basic freedoms -- all of these will be the first to suffer from the worsening climate of state repression in the name of state-supported Islamic orthodoxy."

"No less is today's enactment aimed at the Western world, to intimidate anyone from criticizing radical Islam and those who commit violence in its name," said Neuer.

Proponents of free speech celebrated one small victory, however.

Successful campaigning by an international human rights coalition, including the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty and UN Watch, led to a decline in support for the resolution compared to last year's vote, which had garnered 108 in support, 51 against, and 25 abstentions.

The proposed draft declaration for the UN's April 2009 "Durban II" conference on racism includes numerous provisions on the "defamation" of Islam. Denmark has threatened to walk out if they are included.

---- SIGN Appeal “Boycott Durban II” --- Against the Durban Review Conference of the UN!

Informations on the petition “Boycott Durban 2!” Signatures BackgroundFeedbackBanners for blogs and websites

Video Playlist: Durban II - The UN Conference to Promote Antisemitism

A Muslim-Programmed Inhuman Rights Council? Why the UN's Durban Review Conference Must Be Boycotted Durban reloaded Israel will not participate in the Durban 2 Conference Durban II: An Early Test

Durban II – a new battlefront opens The Pathology of Durban II Denmark threatens boycott of Durban II Danish foreign minister threatens Western boycott of Durban II

UN Human Rights Council banned Discussion of religious questions Incredulous UN Bans Criticism of Islam

Islamic states draw new battle lines over Freedom of Expression Petition for defence of individual rights at the UN Human Rights Council Growing opposition to the concept of "defamation of religion"

The UN must not give in to Islamic criticism In the name of Islamophobia, will the OIC soon ‘Rule the Waves’ at the UN General Assembly and the UN Human Rights Council? Religion and Freedom of Expression in the Human Rights Council

Criticism of religion is not blasphemy An Islamic Blasphemy Law? Let’s Call Their Bluff Islamic states draw new battle lines over Freedom of Expression

Creeping Dhimmitude at the United Nations World’s Press Criticises UN Human Rights Council IHEU "ambushed" at Human Rights Council

Universal Human Rights and "Human Rights in Islam"Universal Declaration of Human RightsIslamic Law vs Human RightsCairo Declaration on Human Rights in Islam - Diverges from the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in key respects

Why Europeans Should Support Israel

1948, Israel, and the Palestinians - The True Story The Hamas Charter - The Covenant of the Hamas 1988 New translation of Hamas charter contains anti-semitism Arab anti-Semitism is strategic threat, says study

Islam’s Jew-Hating Hadith Matter Today Antisemitism in the Qur’an: Motifs and Historical Manifestations The Legacy of Islamic Antisemitism Hitler's Legacy: Islamic Antisemitism in the Middle East

Islam and democracy: The theory - and the practice?

ALGERIA: Political killings, Censorship, Harassment & Intimidation

BAHRAIN: Executions, Abuses of detainees & Censorship

EGYPT: Censorship, Limited Judicial Independence & Police Tortures

IRAN: Torture, Repressed Minorities, Discriminated Women, Unfair Trials, Censorship & Executions

LYBIA: Censorship, Killings of Demonstrators & Prisoners

MOROCCO: Discriminated Women, Abused Prisoners, Migrants & Refugees

OMAN: Discriminated Migrants, Abused Woman & Domestic Workers, Trafficking in Human Beings

IRAQ: Violence against women, Thousands of killed Civilians & Executions

KUWAIT: Torture, Abuse of Migrant Workers & Executions

QUATAR: Violence against Women, Human Trafficking, Torture & ill-Treatment

TUNISIA: Censorship, Limited Judicial Independence, Torture & ill-Treatment

SAUDI ARABIA: Violence against Women, Migrant worker Abuse, Torture, Unfair Trials, Censorship & Executions

SYRIA: Censorship, Torture, Arbitrary Detention, Discrimination of Woman & Minorities

UNITED ARAB EMIRATES: Stoning, Flogging, Death Penalties & Cruel Judicial Punishments

YEMEN: Executions, Censorship, Political Prisoners & Unfair Trials