Political Islam 11 January 2013
Someone wrote in reply to the "Un-Merry Christmas to the Christians from Islam newsletter: ... Oh My God. How wrong can you be? Please have more knowledge before you say anything.
Most of what you wrote about Islam is wrong. Islam has several verses which contribute to peace on earth and tolerance to all. Some people do not adhere to this and happen to be Muslim so you regard that as consensus. Its interesting to justify your sense of Islam you bring in Boko Haram and the kidnapping of the Christian girl for blasphemy. (Your average Muslims??). I hold a degree in Islamic studies and am now studying a post grad; so I know what I am talking about. As a Christian myself I know we too have our faults in society but on no account does that represent the mass....
So you hold yourself to be an expert?
Well, there are only two experts--Allah and Mohammed. Islam is found in the Koran, Sira and Hadith. Everything else is comment, including your post grad courses.
The "several verses which contribute to peace on earth and tolerance for all" in the Koran are all abrogated by later jihadic verses. The man who does not understand the use of abrogation should not comment about the Koran.
Seek critical study of source texts, not university propaganda. After you have read the Koran in the correct time order (to see the abrogation) and read the Sira by Ishaq or al Tabari and Bukhari, come back and comment. (21% of Bukharis hadiths are about murderous jihad.) Master the Sunna of Mohammed and then talk to us.
Look at Mohammed's life. He preached the religion of Islam in Mecca for 13 years and got 150 Meccans to become Muslims. He moved to Medina and attacked every single neighbor he had, without exception. In his rise to absolute power he was responsible for an event of violence on the average of every 6 weeks for the last 9 years of his life. Peace on earth, what a joke!
Boko Haram jihadists follow pure Medinan Islam. You confuse Muslim-ology with the study of Islam. Start with Islam to understand Muslims. Do not start with Muslims to understand Islamic doctrine.
Another thing about those peaceful believers who make up the mass of Muslims, do you notice that they dont condemn the murder of Christians? They are silent. Do they teach you in your post grad Islam classes that "silence is consent?
Have you ever condemned the jihadic murder of Christians? Buddhists? Hindus? Jews? Over 270 million non-Muslims were murdered by jihad over the last 1400 years. And you speak of peace.
Christians who are silent in the face of Islamic jihad against Christians, Jews, Buddhists, Hindu and atheists are giving consent to this brutality. There have been over 20,000 jihad attacks since 9/11. What noise are you making about that? Silence is consent.
Your apologist education has made you a deluded dhimmi. What is truly tragic is that you represent the pious pacifism of todays Christians. You are so nice, but you are ruled by fear. It is odd how many Christians live in fear, yet Jesus told his followers, again and again, not to fear. Put down the gospel of nice and take up the Gospel of Christ and take on spiritual warfare.
Oh, and you Jews, take up the mantle of Aaron, Gideon, Deborah and David. Let the Hindus remember the Bhagavad Gita. Let the Buddhists take a lesson from Rinzai Zen.
We either stand together in this civilizational war or we will all be annihilated. See Turkey, Egypt, North Africa, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran and the other graveyards of Kafir civilization.
Bill Warner, Director, Center for the Study of Political Islam Permalink: /blog/mercy-to-the-guilty-is-cruelty-to-the-innocent/ copyright (c) CBSX, LLC, politicalislam.com Use as needed, just give credit and do not edit. www.politicalislam.com
"___ "You confuse Muslim-ology with the study of Islam."
Just one quibble, however. Why not state that Islam has THREE experts, Allah, Gabriel, and Muhammad? To construe Islamic expertise in this way would be useful for teaching the ignorant, e.g. "Friend", about the rudiments of Islam and about its founder's alleged mystical experiences. And surely if Islam were true, Gabriel would be one of its experts.
"Say, 'Whoever is an enemy to Gabriel - it is [none but] he who has brought the Qur'an down upon your heart, [O Muhammad], by permission of Allah , confirming that which was before it and as guidance and good tidings for the believers.' "
-Koran 2:97 (http://quran.com/2)" (continue reading...)