The initial reactions to reports of the brutal attacks and sexual assault of CBS reporter Lara Logan, which took place at Cairos Tahrir Square following Hosni Mubaraks resignation, were depressingly predictable.
Like countless victims of sexual assault before her, the blame was heaped on Logan herself for being attractive, and for putting herself in that environment. Reactions of conservative commentators like Debbie Schlussel, who not only blamed Logan, but also blamed Islam, were hardly surprising.
However, reactions like that of reporter Nir Rosen, admired by left-leaning progressives, who trivialized the horrific attacks on Ms. Logan by tweeting that he is "rolling [his] eyes at all the attention shell get, starkly demonstrated that misogyny is alive and kicking in all quarters. For anyone who doubts this, it suffices to compare reactions when CNN reporter Anderson Cooper was beaten while covering the protests in Cairo.
Reactions in Egypt were far more sympathetic (and it was a group of women and army officers who reportedly came to Logans rescue and extricated her from the mob). Some of the activists who had been at Tahrir, like the well-known blogger Mahmoud Salem, condemned the attack, and shortly after the incident, a Facebook page was set up to denounce the assaults.
Many of the activists who participated in the 18-day revolt against Mubarak reacted with a mix of surprise and deflation, for if anything, the atmosphere in Tahrir Square had been, for most, refreshingly free of the sexual taunts and harassment that typify many womens daily experiences on the streets of Egypt. Some were quick to suggest that the attacks were perpetrated by pro-Mubarak thugs, and an isolated and extreme example.
Certainly and thankfully, what happened to Lara Logan on the night of February 11, 2011 was both isolated and extreme for that evening. But it is hardly the first such incident to occur. The attack on Logan may very well have been orchestrated by hired thugs. After all, just a little over a week before Mubaraks resignation, such thugs had been set loose upon the protesters at Tahrir Square, with several fatalities and hundreds of injuries.
For years, these thugs-for-hire have been a constant feature of protests in Egypt. On May 25, 2005, a day activists later dubbed "black Wednesday, during protests held against amendments to Article 76 of the Egyptian Constitution, hired thugs sexually assaulted female protestors, including women journalists covering the protests, while security forces idly stood by and let it happen. A female activist and friend told me later, "after that day, my parents begged me not to attend any protests anymore. The message to women was clear your gender will be used against you if you choose to participate in demonstrations.
Many activists pointed out that the governments complicity in the sexual assaults against female protesters only reinforced general societal attitudes towards sexual harassment in Egypt. When the state appears not only to sanction, but also to sponsor it, is it any wonder that men can get away with harassing women, they asked?
The question was answered in the fall of 2006, when widely-circulated images of roving gangs of men chasing and assaulting women in downtown Cairo during the Eid el-Fitr holiday were met with dismissal, disbelief and derision. Former First Lady, Suzanne Mubarak went so far as to suggest that such incidents were exaggerated by the media to tarnish the countrys image (...)